Top Ten Musicals

17 April, 2008
Rat Fink

The hard part about this list is not narrowing down the number of my fave musicals, but putting them in order. I don’t have a lot of “favorite” Broadway shows. It’s actually a very small collection.

Top Ten Broadway Musicals, According to Me

10. The Sound of Music – Rodgers & Hammerstein. I was Maria in my high school production. That’s why this gets the #10 spot. (Ok, that, and Gabe likes it, and I want to humor him.)

9. Godspell – Stephen Schwartz. For a sixties musical with then-contemporary songs, it never sounds dated. Love it.

8. Forever Plaid – A huge favorite ever since I saw my nephew, Jason, play Sparky in a professional production in North Carolina back in 2002. Awesome old standards, sung in tight 4-part harmony. And don’t forget hilarious.

7. Les MisérablesSchoenberg & Boublil. Beautifully written and staged, it had a long run on Broadway. Saw it three times. I haven’t seen the movie version, though.

6. West Side Story – Leonard Bernstein & Stephen Sondheim. Based loosely on Romeo and Juliet, this was the first musical I ever saw that did not have a happy ending. The music is gorgeous, and not for weak singers.

5. Seven Brides for Seven Brothers – Gene DePaul, Johnny Mercer & Al Kasha. The songs are wonderful and the movie is a delight; two years ago, I music-directed the stage version. Most fun I ever had directing a show.

4. Funny Girl – Jule Styne, Bob Merrill. Ok, so I had the lead in this one in high school, too. Most fun I ever had acting in a show.

3. Singin’ in the Rain – Herb Brown & Arthur Freed. Best movie musical, period. Ever.

2. Phantom of the Opera – Andrew Lloyd Webber. Yeah, I know. All the theater snobs are saying, “Ew…how 1986.” Go ahead. And choke on your sashimi while you’re at it. But for me to see a show on Broadway, in Toronto (with Colm Wilkinson as the phantom) and Cleveland for a total of eight times and still bawl all the way through the second act….that’s some powerful music. I will always love it.

1. Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street – Stephen Sondheim. I never liked the Broadway stage version soundtracks. Too much wobbly-opera-singer vibrato. The songs sounded way too melodramatic for my taste. But the 2007 movie….well, you know all about that.

Notify of

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments