The “post for another day”

2 January, 2015
Rat Fink

Often referenced but seldom written, it’s here: the “post for another day.” It’s the one where I talk about an uncomfortable truth.

I’m losing my singing ability.

It’s been bothering me for about a year now, and though I’ve referenced it on a couple of occasions here and there, I’ve never really talked about it in a public manner until now. Whether it’s caused by advancing age, genetics, too many years of rock and roll, I don’t know — but my singing days are pretty much over, and this time, for good. If I told you there haven’t been many, many private tears and general anguish about it, I’d be lying. If I told you that I don’t seethe with sad envy when I hear singers my age (and older, like Tony Bennett, Sting, Daryl Hall, others) still knocking it out of the park, I’d be lying.

If I told you this doesn’t terrify me, I’d be lying. Performing is all I’ve really ever known since about the age of 11, when I started singing with my sister and our friends in a tiny little Baptist church in Milwaukee. There hasn’t been a single day since then when singing hasn’t been at the forefront of just about everything I do.

This morning, I read an article about Bono of U2, facing the possibility that he’ll never play guitar again. I couldn’t imagine not doing the one thing you love the most — until now. My hope is that I can adopt a healthy attitude about it all, and arrive at a sane balance between remembering the voice I had, and dealing with the one I now have, which is decidedly weak in two major areas:

  1. I can no longer control the quality of a sustained pitch. Fine motor control over the laryngeal musculature is becoming more difficult; sometimes impossible. Therefore, I struggle to control the tonal integrity of a long phrase.
  2. Accuracy in moving from note to note has been severely compromised. I can no longer sing multi-note phrases with 100% pitch accuracy. Of the two weak areas, this one is the more horrific for me to accept.

I’ve done some research on the aging voice, and ultimately, what it comes down to is control – specifically, lack thereof. I can no longer make the voice manifest what’s in my head. Truly, it must be similar to, say, dealing with the aftermath of a stroke, when the brain is completely functional with regard to cogent thoughts, but the mouth won’t form the words that express them. Indeed, I can’t find the words to accurately express to you my desperate frustration at this reality. I suppose it’s the same frustration an aging athlete feels, when her body can’t perform like it used to, even though her mind knows exactly what form and technique she wants to use.

On occasions when I’ve lodged a passing complaint about my situation, well-meaning friends have said things like, “I’d take your voice as it is right now any day,” or “Don’t be silly; you still have plenty of years left.” Those comments, though spoken in a spirit of love and encouragement, I must admit, sting. We’re not talking a passive hobby here, or an avocation I enjoy. Rather, singing has been my job since 1980. It’s among the things that can be counted on three fingers that I do relatively well, and now it’s fading away. It’s a jagged enormous pill, and on days like today, I feel like I’m choking on it.

Conversely, I know I have to put things in their proper perspective. I can still walk, think, write, speak, teach, play my instruments, laugh, and be generally annoying. I rejoice in that, and I don’t take it for granted for a New York minute, because it could be a whole lot worse. But I don’t want to be like Frank Sinatra and Rosemary Clooney, who stayed at the fair way, way too long, to the point where their most ardent admirers winced. That’s not going to be me.

I “officially” retired from singing in the summer of 2012, resurfacing only to record the mini-album for my Daddy a year later. Last month, an area jazz society asked me to do a gig on the 5th of January. I thought about it for a few days, and ended up turning them down, because I would have just stressed and worried about it every single day of my Christmas break, and I didn’t want to do that to the Thriller or the rest of my family. It is time to hang it up, and my resolution for 2015 is to find positive ways to spin it and ultimately be comfortable with it.

So hey, don’t feel too bad for me. My students are very forgiving of my old-lady modeling in rehearsal, and that’s all that matters. I’m on the horse till it throws me. But truth be told, I will always miss what was…whatever that is. I suppose it’s to be expected.

Notify of

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
2 January, 2015 9:35 am

So many of us (especially me) have enjoyed and been thrilled over the years with that powerful voice of yours. I remember when you were pretty young, maybe 10 or 11, I loved hearing you sing. We all knew that, from a young age, you would go places with singing. You did, you have. Being your sis, the only I say about it is – you are more than your singing voice. I know it’s hard to accept the voice not being what it was, but we all love you anyway. You can now live and *sing* vicariously through your… Read more »

2 January, 2015 9:49 am

In my “mind’s ear” I still, clearly hear you singing “Moondance;” after more than fifteen years have passed it still was better to me than the original! I have never forgotten that evening…never will! ReplyRat Fink Reply:January 2nd, 2015 at 9:54 amGood memories, my dear friend. I’m hanging onto those as well! Shouting the occasional rocker remains in my purview…ya never know! Much love! ReplyDavid Reply:January 2nd, 2015 at 10:43 amThe thing about all this aging stuff is that it is always gradual yet surprises us at every turn. I can still do everything I used to do at 40,… Read more »

Ross Bonander
2 January, 2015 11:00 am

That’s brutal. I’m sorry. And I’ve never even heard your singing voice.


Rat Fink Reply:

Thanks, Ross. Just gotta look ahead to the next adventure is all. I’m planning on 2015 being full of new opportunities!


3 January, 2015 3:07 pm

Wish I was there to give you a huge ((HUG)) right now. And I feel your pain…really, I do. Just know that, if you ever get an itch to test the waters, or sing a few songs with your old buddy from the Apex days, there’s a quaint little smokey piano bar at a top-notch steakhouse in Dallas that will welcome you with open arms & hearts – ANY time!!! XOXOXOX ReplyRat Fink Reply:January 6th, 2015 at 6:01 amHey, shouting out some old rockers with you is always an exception. Write me in — in pen! XO And I’m amazed… Read more »

6 January, 2015 1:15 pm

Hey where have I been and why am I just NOW reading this! Garsh I can’t imagine how you feel, losing your instrument like that. Have you seen a doctor, do you have those node things or anything like that?

Could it be anything like losing strength in the diaphragm and not getting the support you need? Sounds familiar LOL


6 January, 2015 4:03 pm

Awww, Linda. I love you!


Skyler Stevens
Skyler Stevens
13 March, 2015 3:42 pm

*Creeping on your blog* I’m more of a reader, not a commenter but I had to on this one. This honestly made me sad, Jax. I hope I can find something that I feel so passionate about one day. Even if it does eventually have to end. Don’t worry, your students love you either way! I am sincerely sorry though, I can’t imagine what this is like. ReplyRat Fink Reply:March 15th, 2015 at 7:11 amSkyler, you are a joy. Thank you for your kind words, and I know there will be something that grabs your soul one day! I hope… Read more »